You can go to “gifts” and “Shop By” > “Dylan’s Candy Bar” and all 5 items show up.
You can type in Search “Dylan” and all 5 items show up
You can type in Search “Dylan’s” or “Dylan’s Candy” and only 3 items show up.
All items have the “Dylan’s Candy” in the title but when you search for “Dylan’s Candy” only 3 show. What could be causing this? I have the same settings for all 5 products and the Visibility all have “Catalog and Search”
Try manually retyping the apostrophes for all 5 of those products. I can see there is a difference in them, which I think means its not always recognizing the apostrophe when you search for it. Though 1 of the 3 products that comes up does have the angled apostrophe.